Participant 1
Initial description: I just read the instruction thought rule was to transform the input to the output for this task
Final description: very confusing
Participant 2
Initial description: Using the bottom rows and filling in the black with the top rows
Final description: Using the bottom rows and filling in the black with the top rows
Participant 3
Initial description: divide the input into 3 5x5 grids. Starting with the pink and black bottom third, compare with the dark blue and black upper third. Any square that is black should be colored dark blue if there is a dark blue square in a corresponding position. Do the same for the light blue square.
Final description: divide the input into 3 5x5 grids. Starting with the pink and black bottom third, compare with the dark blue and black upper third. Any square that is black should be colored dark blue if there is a dark blue square in a corresponding position. Do the same for the light blue square.
Participant 4
Initial description: Create a 6x6 grid using the pattern of the magenta pixels. Take the dark blue pattern and fit in the squares that would show if placed under the magenta. Do the same with the light blue, dropping it into place behind the darker blue.
Final description: Create a 6x6 grid using the pattern of the magenta pixels. Take the dark blue pattern and fit in the squares that would show if placed under the magenta. Do the same with the light blue, dropping it into place behind the darker blue.
Participant 5
Initial description: Overlap the colors, such that pink>blue>light blue
Final description: Overlap the colors such that pink>blue>light blue. Solved incorrectly first time because I forgot to fill out all the regular blue squares!
Participant 6
Initial description: Combine the 3 colored grids into a single 5x5 grid and fill in the squares according to the patterns of each color and priority. Assign pink top priority and fill in all pink squares, then fill any non-pink squares with dark blue squares, then fill in any remaining squares with light blue if its pattern calls for it.
Final description: Combine the 3 colored grids into a single 5x5 grid and fill in the squares according to the patterns of each color and priority. Assign pink top priority and fill in all pink squares, then fill any non-pink squares with dark blue squares, then fill in any remaining squares with light blue if its pattern calls for it.
Participant 7
Initial description: Incorporate the three sets of colors together in a 5x5 grid.
Final description: The rule was to merge the three colors together in a 5x5 grid.
Participant 8
Initial description: Magenta stays where it is in the 5x5 grid, slide the blue grids down as if they are behind the magenta
Final description: Think of magenta, light blue, and dark blue as layers. Magenta stays where it is and is on top, dark blue moves down with layer underneath magenta, then light blue moves down with layer underneath dark blue
Participant 9
Initial description: Create a 5x5 grid and then layer each of the color patterns on top of each other.
Final description: Create a 5x5 grid and then layer each of the color patterns on top of each other, ensuring that the pink color is on top.
Participant 10
Initial description: Put each 5x5 color group on top of each other, with pink on top and light blue on the bottom.
Final description: Put each 5x5 color group on top of each other, with pink on top and light blue on the bottom.
Participant 11
Initial description: Combine the colored patterns into one 5x5 grid, one color at a time, starting from the top, so that they sit one on top of the other.
Final description: Combine the colors into a single 5x5 grid, so that they are overlapping. Starting with the 2nd color, then overwrite with the 1st color, and finally the 3rd color goes on top.
Participant 12
Initial description: The pink pattern appears to stay the same but its on a smaller 5x5 grid. Some of the light and dark blue squares are moved down into the pink pattern in their original places. Its quite confusing.
Final description: I tried my best. I moved light and dark blue pieces into the empty areas of the pink pattern, following their original patterns, but no. I just dont get it.
Participant 13
Initial description: Create a checkerboard pattern by alternating between the two colors in each row.
Final description: Create a checkerboard pattern by alternating between the two colors in each row.
