Participant 1

Initial description: The rule is to match the colors diagonally with the the corresponding color box on the outside of the grey square.

Final description: The rule is to match the colors diagonally with the the corresponding color box on the outside of the grey square.


Attempt 1: Correct

Participant 2

Initial description: create a checkerboard pattern in the inside using the colored squares on the outside as the template.

Final description: create a checkerboard pattern in the inside using the colored squares on the outside as the template.


Attempt 1: Correct

Participant 3

Initial description: Create four-square colored squares inside gray square corresponding to the color outside the square (should be two four-squares of each color in a checkerboard pattern when finished)

Final description: Create four-square colored squares inside gray square corresponding to the color outside the square (should be two four-squares of each color in a checkerboard pattern when finished)


Attempt 1: Correct

Participant 4

Initial description: Fill the 4x4 space inside the gray squares with 4 2x2 squares. The colors alternate. The color of the single square is the same as the color of the 2x2 square closest to it. Then the colors alternate for the other two squares.

Final description: Fill the 4x4 space inside the gray squares with 4 2x2 squares. The colors alternate. The color of the single square is the same as the color of the 2x2 square closest to it. Then the colors alternate for the other two squares.


Attempt 1: Correct

Participant 5

Initial description: I followed the example outputs and just put in the same pattern

Final description: I followed the example outputs and just put in the same pattern


Attempt 1: Correct

Participant 6

Initial description: To make a 6x6x6x6 box with 2 2x2 squares in blue and red diagonally from each other with the outside red and blue square being the lead.

Final description: To make a 6x6x6x6 box with 2 2x2 squares in blue and red diagonally from each other with the outside red and blue square being the lead.


Attempt 1: Correct

Participant 7

Initial description: I created the gray box squares and placed the 2 colored bricks in a new location on the grid

Final description: I rearranged the colored blocks to fit in the new grid size.


Attempt 1: Incorrect
Attempt 2: Incorrect
Attempt 3: Incorrect

Participant 8

Initial description: Color the inner grey square in a checkerboard pattern, using the colors in the outer corners as a guide

Final description: Color the inner grey square in a checkerboard pattern, using the colors in the outer corners as a guide


Attempt 1: Correct

Participant 9

Initial description: create a diagonal patter inside of a gey square

Final description: create a diagonal patter inside of a gey square


Attempt 1: Correct

Participant 10

Initial description: The grey circle has its inner squares filled with the colors in the edges of the outer square, the outer colors each take up 8 smaller squares but grouped in diagonally opposite groups of 4

Final description: The grey circle has its inner squares filled with the colors in the edges of the outer square, the outer colors each take up 8 smaller squares but grouped in diagonally opposite groups of 4


Attempt 1: Correct

Participant 11

Initial description: Make a 6x6 square within the 10x10 grid. Keep the outside squares the same color and fill in the 6x6 square with the corresponding colors from the outside.

Final description: Make a 6x6 square within the 10x10 grid. Keep the outside squares the same color and fill in the 6x6 square with the corresponding colors from the outside.


Attempt 1: Correct

Participant 12

Initial description: Grid is the same, and the blocks outside the gray square influence the inside in a diagonal pattern. Maroon diagonally to the right, blue to the left.

Final description: Grid is the same, and the blocks outside the gray square influence the inside in a diagonal pattern. Maroon diagonally to the right, blue to the left.


Attempt 1: Correct

Participant 13

Initial description: Recreate the first pattern and use the color of the squares on the outside to create a checkerboard inside that corrisponds with the color on the outside of the gray square.

Final description: Recreate the first pattern and use the color of the squares on the outside to create a checkerboard inside that corrisponds with the color on the outside of the gray square.


Attempt 1: Correct

Participant 14

Initial description: First off the grid was 10x10 with a square of gray in the middle. The 2 "outside" blocks did not change position but their color determined the color inside gray square in a diagonal pattern.

Final description: I am absolutely certain I had it right the first time - I have studied this ad nauseum and there can be no other solution. Is there deception inherent in this study?


Attempt 1: Incorrect
Attempt 2: Incorrect
Attempt 3: Incorrect

Participant 15

Initial description: the inner squares are filled in along the corresponding diagonal color.

Final description: the inner squares are filled in along the corresponding diagonal color.


Attempt 1: Correct